Disciples Unlimited
Let's chat ...
  • Home
  • Info
  • Blog
  • Partner Churches
  • Africa
  • Giving AUD
  • Giving ZAR
  • Store
  • Contact
  • New Leadership Book

5 thoughts on the Royal Commission

15/11/2012

5 Comments

 
Picture
The Australian Prime Minister has announced A Royal Commission into institutional responses to allegations of child sex abuse in Australia.

5 thoughts:

1.        Let's welcome it
This is long overdue. From time immemorial, unspeakable evil has been committed against children with apparent impunity. Right now there are victims who are hurting – they feel worthless, unheard and disempowered.  Many of us have dedicated our lives to protecting young people. Anything which helps achieve this is an answer to prayer. All Christians should welcome this Royal Commission so that what has been kept in the darkness can be brought into the light.  We need a way of protecting the innocent and punishing the guilty. This is a time to bring healing. This is a time to bring justice.

2.         Abuse will be exposed
Abuse has occurred in families, in institutions, in schools, in sporting clubs … anywhere where children gather is a likely place for abuse to occur. Some have used the cloak of religion to mask their misdoings. There can be no doubt that abuse has occurred in churches.

3.         “Cover-ups” will be exposed
Compounding the degradation of abuse has been the wall of silence where sins have been concealed. Too many places – churches included – have simply ‘hushed-up’ cases of abuse to protect themselves. All this has only served to increase the pain of the victims.

4.         All churches will be suspect
To a cynical world, the findings of this Royal Commission will reinforce the widespread thought that ‘churches can’t be trusted’.  There will be some horrendous headlines and sickening stories over the coming years.  People will probably be far more forgiving of hospitals, schools and community groups where abuse may have occurred. But the Christian church is a popular target for all sorts of attacks, and we Christians can expect that the integrity of us all will be under fire. 

A challenge for us all will be – how can we keep reaching out to a world that is more and more distrusting of us?  And it’s no use claiming “It wasn’t our church” – “It wasn’t our denomination”.  In the eyes of the world, all churches will be tarred with same brush.

What will you do to keep promoting Christ when the sins of our past are being paraded so visibly?  A challenge for us all.

5.         The innocent might be brought down
In a world that has been far too passive on the issue of child protection, the pro-active nature of a Royal Commission might well have some unintended victims. If a false allegation is made, perfectly innocent people might have their reputations scarred for life.  Even if allegations are later proved to be false, mud sticks.  The damage might already be done.  Careers and reputations of innocent people might be on the line.

Check out your own attitude.  When you hear that someone has been called into the Royal Commission for questioning, will you assume that they are guilty?  Or will you hold with the long-held and fundamental principle of “Innocent until proven guilty”?

The results of this Royal Commission will be for the benefit of everyone.  The process of getting there will no doubt be imbedded with pain.

So … what do you think?



5 Comments
mark mcpherson link
15/11/2012 12:21:20 pm

Some good thoughts Tim but I disagree with some of your sentiments.
I wonder if you'd say the same things if this was a Royal Commission mainly into say Rotary, Boy Scouts, NSW Soccer, etc.
You say: "People will probably be far more forgiving of hospitals, schools and community groups where abuse may have occurred." First, I don't agree. Second, I’m not sure why you’d say such a thing. Three, so what if this was the case? Four, why are you concerned about being forgiving? Shouldn't we be totally non-forgiving?
You also say: "Even if allegations are later proved to be false, mud sticks." etc. Well this is often very true but again, so what? And what is your point?
There's no doubt that the RC into policing brought down some apparently innocent people. But there’s also no doubt that guilty people got away. It would be better to highlight this issue.
Also, do you think some groups, (eg the Church) will highlight these cases of ‘innocent people being brought down’ but perhaps not highlight the great good the RC will do? After all there is a powerful spokes-group for guilty priests but not so for the individual who has suffered because of the abuse. The Church would do well to not worry about the former but worry about the latter. .

Reply
Sue Wells
15/11/2012 04:18:06 pm

I agree Tim. Justice should be done. Forgiveness should be given as the christian victims deal with their pain, and in their time as they process it. This can't be demanded of them by others. They are the ones who have to get their thoughts about what happened to them in line with their understanding of who Jesus is. This will take decades in some situations. Speaking from experience this is true.

Reply
madeleine Nicholas
17/11/2012 11:00:24 am

I dread the publicity which will consume our Media. I hope and pray that justice will be truly done, not just appear to be done.

Reply
Bruce Herbert
19/11/2012 03:26:11 pm

Fraught subject - much pain too long covered up. I suspect some child abuse has been around and "covered up" for as long as history goes back. Doesn't in any way make it right, indeed it makes me wonder what is it about this time in history that has led us to finally make it public (its always been unacceptable, just not pubic). Sorry I simply can't accept the comment made by one that we should be "totally unforgiving", and be happy to "bring down" innocents in the pursuit of the guilty. Our entire legal system is built on the premise that it is better to release 10 guilty people than punish an innocent. I didn't make that up, generations of our forebears, their judiciary and elected governments developed and honed it. To change that principle is to change our society fundamentally and revert to the lynch mob. We must punish, we must seek justice, but neither of those are lost by also forgiving.
Reminder from history - even when faced with the unimaginable horrors of German and Japanese war criminals after WW2, the western powers rose above the mob and gave presumption of innocence, due process, proper trials and defence counsel to all. Most were punished, many killed by hanging, but some - who the balance of factual evidence couldn't convict beyond reasonable doubt, were actually set free. We owe as much to anyone, even accused child molesters...

Reply
John Warren link
20/11/2012 07:19:08 am

Love your work Tim. I was discussing this with some (mostly non Christian) work colleagues a few days ago. It really brought home to me your point 4. I think that it will be a disaster for the general reputation of the church. In fact what has already happened here and overseas has been a disaster, and this will simply magnify it. That's not a reason to not have the Royal Commission, but it certainly is a consequence of it.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Grumpy Old 
    Youth Pastor

    The ramblings of a 
    Youth Pastor who's
    old enough to 
    know better ...

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture







    Tim's latest book 
    on preaching.
    Order now in our 
    secure online store

    Order Now

    Also available:
    "Speak Like a Train Driver"
    For speakers, trainers, teachers and presenters
    Order Now
    "

    Archives

    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    November 2012